Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Hard disagree. How many paragraphs of fawning over the unique culture of the Bay Area must I endure before he arrives at the point?

Such gems as

> I like SF house parties, where people take off their shoes at the entrance and enter a space in which speech can be heard over music, which feels so much more civilized than descending into a loud bar in New York. It’s easy to fall into a nerdy conversation almost immediately with someone young and earnest.



The next sentence is “The Bay Area has converged on Asian-American modes of socializing”

As if there is a single Asian-American culture and no Asian-Americans like going out to bars…

The whole piece is littered with weird over generalizations over huge and diverse groups of people.


It happens with more authors. Blogging and self-promotion on social media easily leads to fast and sensational "insights". It is fast food: feels good, easily digestible, way better than a thorough study involving the required ifs-and-buts and the hard work of trying to find blind spots in one's own perspective.

The latter profile isn't suitable for short content bites and doesn't sell to a large audience. The former does, but comes with a cost only the uninformed aren't aware of.

I can sympathize with that though. Non-fiction in general is a hard sell.


Yep. This is Jeff Foxxworthy level social analysis.

Just quoting a paragraph means nothing, what’s the actual problem you have here?

I’ve lived in both SF and now NYC, and that characterization is painting with a broad brush, but isn’t ridiculous.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: