Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>I can only speak to my experience, certified devices by the largest firms will mostly not interoperate (fails around authN).

>Apple: Keeps Thread credentials locked to HomeKit's border routers.

>Google: Shares some credentials, but only within Google Account environment.

>Amazon: TBD, but their Matter implementation is mostly cloud-tied.

>Samsung: Hybrid approach; still best when used inside SmartThings, their 1.4 update seems to support for joining existing Thread networks. Still have to test it.

>So, even though Thread theoretically allows full interoperability, no vendor wants to be reduced to a dumb router in someone else’s ecosystem.

>there is no easy way to bridge Apple Thread to Home Assistant or Google Thread, even though it is theoretically supposed to be possible from a protocol standpoint.

>If you have such solutions, let me know, because I would take full advantage of it, and will regale your contributions in multiple home automation threads.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: