Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You're looking at this way too narrowly.

The dichotomy isn't between helping people outside your community or within your community.

That dichotomy I'm highlighting is between having a culture of helping one another or not having that culture.

The communities that aren't helping those within their community, typically aren't helping people outside their community either. There are plenty of cities and neighborhoods in this country where there isn't much community service, participation in the community and taking pride in helping your community succeed relative to other communities out there. I grew up in a predominantly Jewish town as a kid. The level of involvement from the parents in the school system was off the charts. Since moving away from that community, I've never once seen anyplace else that came even close to that level of civic involvement.

It doesn't even have to be community based on race. It can be as simple as volunteering in your neighborhood or city.

Communities that grow rich have a culture of service to one another whether that community is delineated along racial or geographical lines or if that community is global. The size of the group or whether there is exclusion or not is orthogonal to my point. This culture change is easiest to begin at home and within your community.

One of the big differences I've noticed between liberals and conservatives is that with liberals, community starts with the world, then moves to the country, then the state, then the county, then the city/town, then the neighborhood, then the family. With conservatives it's the opposite. Community and obligation to one another begins with the family and moves to the neighborhood, then the city/town, then county, then state, then country and then world.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: